Cutthroat Island

You'll Never Make It Out of Here Alive, Pirate!2 pts

Make it out of there alive, pirate, and escape "His Majesty's Prison"

You'll Never Make It Out of Here Without Getting Hit, Pirate!5 pts

Make it out of "His Majesty's Prison" without getting hit

Rocky Escape2 pts

Successfully maneuver your cart across this treacherous path and beat "Quarry"

Redcoat Roadkill5 pts

Beat "Quarry" having run over all 14 Redcoats

Merciful Marauders10 pts

Beat "Quarry" without running over more than one Redcoat

A Dirty Town Filled with Rude People2 pts

Acquire the map from uncle Mordechai and beat "Spittalfield"

A Dirty Town Filled with 1-ups2 pts

Find the two hidden 1-ups in Spittalfield

A Dirty Town Cleaned25 pts

As Shaw, using the Brawling fighting style and without dying, defeat at least 50 enemies in Spittalfield. Do not enter the Tavern - you'll be trapped inside if you walk in

Explosive Family Reunion25 pts

As Morgan, defeat the second boss of "Spittalfield", your Uncle Mordechai, by throwing a bomb at him

Get Out!3 pts

Escape Spittalfield on your runaway carriage and beat "Carriage Chase"

Get In!10 pts

Beat "Carriage Chase" without losing a life

You Again?2 pts

Rough the Harbormaster up and beat "Harbour"

You Again but There Are Restrictions Now?10 pts

Using the Brawling fighting style, beat the Harbormaster without crouching or losing a life

Mutiny on the Morning Star2 pts

Quell Scully's rebellion and beat "Mutiny"

Short-Lived Mutiny on the Morning Star25 pts

Quell Scully's rebellion in under 1 minute and 40 seconds

Marooned on Cutthroat Island3 pts

Navigate the perils of the woods on Cutthroat Island and beat "Jungle"

Marooned with a Very Well Hidden 1-up2 pts

Find the very well hidden 1-up in "Jungle"

Wait a Minute... If I Fall I Die?5 pts

Make your way down the precipice and beat "Cliff" (first time)

Wait a Minute... There's a Hidden 1-up Here?2 pts

Find the hidden 1-up in "Cliff" (first time)

Wait a Minute... I Cannot Die?10 pts

As Morgan, navigate "Cliff" (first time) without dying

It's a Platformer Now?5 pts

Survive your way across the several bottomless pits and beat "Treasure Chamber"

It's a Platformer Now AND It Has 8 1-ups?5 pts

Find all 8 hidden 1-ups in "Treasure Chamber"

Here We Go Again5 pts

Descend the precipice again and beat "Cliff" (second time)

Here We Go Again Finding Hidden 1-ups2 pts

Find the 2 hidden 1-ups in "Cliff" (second time)

Here We Go Again Descending the Cliff Without Dying10 pts

As Shaw, navigate "Cliff" (second time) without dying

Squaring up Against the Governor10 pts

Fight to the death with Governor Ainslee and beat "Cove"

Squaring up Against the Governor's Pet25 pts

Beat "Cove" having killed governor Ainslee's pet before killing him

Shaw's Freedom10 pts

As Shaw, defeat Dawg and his men and beat the game

Reclaiming the Morning Star10 pts

As Morgan, defeat Dawg and his men and beat the game

No Blade, No Problem10 pts

Beat the game using the Brawling fighting style

Sweepstakes10 pts

Beat the game having collected all 5 hidden treasure chests to witness the secret "ending"

Who Needs a Treasure Anyway?50 pts

In a single session, accumulate 99999 points as Morgan or Shaw

A Dirty and Rude Treasure Chest2 pts

Find the first secret treasure chest

A Treasure Chest Guarded by a Cat2 pts

Find the second secret treasure chest

A Top Secret Treasure Chest2 pts

Find the third secret treasure chest

A Very Risky Treasure Chest2 pts

Find the fourth secret treasure chest

A Treasure Chest That Is Closer than You Think2 pts

Find the final secret treasure chest

A Taste of His Own Medicine10 pts

Find a giant hammer and give one of the large pirates a taste of their own medicine